Modifier 58 Versus 78; Which Should You Use?

Modifier 58 Versus 78; Which Should You Use?

Sometimes coders are confused when they should apply modifier 58 Staged or Related Procedure or Service by the Same Physician or Other Qualified Health Care Professional During the Postoperative Period and modifier 78 Unplanned Return to the Operating/Procedure Room by the Same Physician or Other Qualified Health Care Professional Following Initial Procedure for a Related Procedure During the Postoperative Period. Let’s discuss each and differentiate the situations in which each is used.

58 – Staged or Related Procedure

58 modifiers can be used for planned or unplanned staged or related procedures. Whether planned or unplanned, the staged procedures are performed to treat the problem that the initial surgery was treating.

Planned Staged or Related Procedure

Planned staged or related procedures are usually associated with reconstruction following major resections. The surgeons who performed the resection do not want to necessarily wait until the 90-day global period ends to start the reconstruction. Often the reconstruction can start the day of or day after the initial surgery. Modifier 58 is used for each stage of the reconstruction so that the surgeon can be paid for the work performed during the global period of the initial surgery. The global period on all modifier 58 procedures are reset and start again based on the global of the new surgery.
An example of a planned staged or related surgery is a patient who had a pharyngectomy for a malignant neoplasm of the pharynx. The surgeon then brought the patient back into the OR 10 days later to reconstruct the pharynx. Modifier 58 is added to pharyngoplasty to indicate that this was a staged procedure.

 Unplanned Staged or Related Procedure

Providers are encouraged to perform the most conservative actions to solve a patient’s problems and CPT® global rules should not penalize the provider if that conservative approach does not achieve the results that the surgeon was looking for. Because the patient is usually in the surgical global period when it is identified that the conservative approach did not achieve the desired outcome, the modifier 58 enables the surgeon to be paid when she must go back into surgery and do a more radical procedure than was initially performed. The global period restarts whenever the modifier 58 is used. One way you can determine that the modifier 58 applies is that the surgeon is treating the same problem that the original surgery was treating.
For example, a patient was admitted to the hospital with gangrenous toes and vascular insufficiency. The surgeon does a vascular bypass in addition to debriding the toes to return vascular flow to the foot. 30-days post op, the patient’s toes are still gangrenous, and it appears that the vascular bypass did not take. Although repeated debridements were performed in the global period, the toes continue to deteriorate. It is finally decided at 40 days post-op that the foot needs to be amputated. The amputation, which is more radical than the conservative vascular bypass is coded with a modifier 58. The debridements done during the global period of the vascular bypass are also billed with a modifier 58 because the bypass had not yet achieved the desired outcome and the debridements were needed.

78 – Return to the Operating Room

Unlike the modifier 58, which is treating the same problem that was treated by the initial surgery, modifier 78 treats a problem or condition created by the initial surgery. The initial surgery creates an outcome, a complication that requires the surgeon to bring the patient back to the Operating Room to repair or correct. Medicare only covers treatment of surgical complications that require a return to the Operating Room (or endoscopy suite). This applies to surgeries that the modifier 78 applies to.

Examples of Modifier 78 Situations

In the above example with the patient who has the gangrenous toes, suppose the vascular bypass started leaking. The surgeon would need to bring the patient back to the operating room and re-do the bypass, repairing the leaks (a surgical complication) and the 78 modifier would be added to the vascular bypass code. In this case, instead of treating the gangrene and the vascular insufficiency, the surgeon is treating a complication of the first surgery.

Medical coding books

Barbara Cobuzzi

Medical coding books

About Has 99 Posts

Barbara J. Cobuzzi, MBA, CPC, COC, CENTC, CPC-P, CPC-I, CPCO, CMCS, is CEO of CRN Healthcare Solutions and formerly owned a medical billing company. Cobuzzi is a subject matter expert in otolaryngology coding. She provides litigation support as an expert witness for providers and payers and often presents for many local and national organizations. She is also a consulting editor for AAPC’s Otolaryngology Coding Alert newsletter. In 1999, Cobuzzi was named AAPC’s Networker of the Year, and she is a past member of the National Advisory Board. She is one of four founding members of the Monmouth/Ocean, N.J., local chapter and is still active with the chapter.

3 Responses to “Modifier 58 Versus 78; Which Should You Use?”

  1. Bhavani says:

    Thanks for the explanation! Very informative!

  2. Jennifer Garcia says:

    I need help, which modifier to use if the patient had an I&D of the vulva 56405 in the office, the abscess filled up again and the I&D was repeated in the office before the 10th day global period.

  3. Fran Born says:

    The patient had Brain Tumor Surgery 35 days ago. Now comes in with CFS leak, Psuedomeningiocele, with surgical wound dehiscence. He is taken back into the surgery suite for repair of this. Would this be considered a complication or more extensive ? Would it be a 78 or 58?