Ambiguity Surrounding MAO Claim Denials Hampers Fraud Detection

Ambiguity Surrounding MAO Claim Denials Hampers Fraud Detection

Investigation included 55 million records from 2019.

Adjustment codes are sometimes too vague to clearly identify whether a Medicare Advantage Organization (MAO) denied payment for a service, the Office of Inspector General (OIG) concluded in a February 2023 Issue Brief. Without specifics about the services for which the MAO is denying payment, the OIG cannot effectively understand and identify waste, fraud, and abuse.

Deciphering the Records

By analyzing 2019 records, the OIG discovered that although most claims included payment adjustments and adjustment code descriptions, it was difficult to determine whether they were payment denials. For example, an adjustment code may say something like “The procedure or service is inconsistent with the patient’s history,” which does not specify whether the payment was denied. Another frustration is that other instances showed adjustment codes suggesting that the MAO denied payment for a service, but payment was indeed rendered. Requiring MAO’s to denote payment denials on encounter records would improve program oversight and help combat fraud, the OIG said.

The Findings

Investigators also interviewed Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) employees and sent them questionnaires regarding the methods used to identify payment denials in the Medicare and Medicaid data. In addition, the OIG interviewed staff from oversight entities tasked with safeguarding MAO program integrity and staff from CMS’ Medicare Plan Payment Group, attempting to determine the reasons CMS doesn’t require MAOs to submit a denied-claim indicator on encounter records.

The OIG team also found that most 2019 MAO encounter records contained at least one adjustment code and that 55 million of these records contained codes that may indicate the denial of payments by MAOs, whether or not they actually were. The report’s examination concluded that there was no definitive way to identify MA encounter data for denied claims.

“Without an indicator, oversight entities must make separate requests to MAOs asking them to identify denied claims in a subset of their data, which adds time and burden to investigations,” the report stated. “The lack of an indicator limits the scope of efforts to determine the full impact of potential fraud activities in MA.”

Without clear claim designations, it is challenging or impossible for oversight entities to exclude denied claims and review only paid claims in the MAO encounter data, calculate financial exposure due to fraud, investigate complaints that certain MAOs inappropriately deny payments to their providers, and examine suspected providers’ billing activities across many plans.

The Solution

The OIG recommends that CMS require MAOs to definitively express on encounter data records when they have denied payment for a service claim. Implementing this measure would help ensure that the MA program is operating properly by detecting inappropriate billing patterns and investigate fraud, waste, and abuse.

Joy Battistini

medical coding books

About Has 6 Posts

Joy Battistini joined AAPC in 2022 as a development editor for marketing content. She has written Knowledge Center blog posts and edits and writes thought leadership content and the annual salary survey report. Battistini earned a BA in journalism, with a second major in comparative literature, from Indiana University.

One Response to “Ambiguity Surrounding MAO Claim Denials Hampers Fraud Detection”

  1. Denise L. Horn says:

    The MAOs also need to be speficic in the use of the remarks/denial codes. When calling on denied claims, the MAO reps also do not have any further information on these ambiguous denials. This causes much unnecessary work and follow up on the part of the coding/billing/A/R departments. There needs to be clear, definitive, and transparency in the denial reasons and remarks and MAO and representatives fully trained to appropriately answer questions posed by seasoned coders/billers regarding claim denials.