Documentation Requirements for High-Risk Diagnoses
- By Renee Dustman
- In Coding
- March 1, 2024
- 2 Comments
Is your diagnosis coding leading to improper risk adjustment payments to Medicare Advantage organizations?
News of the Office of Inspector General (OIG) auditing Medicare Advantage organizations (MAOs) has dominated conversations among stakeholders for the past year, or better. No MAO is exempt from the federal agency’s oversight of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS’) risk adjustment program.
Specifically, the OIG is looking for MA claims with high-risk diagnosis codes and then questioning the integrity of those claims. The audit outcomes are always the same, with the OIG asserting, “… the diagnosis codes were not supported in the medical records or could not be supported because [health plan] could not locate the medical records and resulted in [dollar amount] in net overpayments.”
Is Medicare Advantage under attack? “Yes,” said Amy Pritchett, CPC, CPMA, CRC, CPCO, CPC-I, CDEO, CDEC, CANPC, CASCC, CCS, CPA-RA, AAPC Approved Instructor, AAPC Fellow, ICD-10-CM/PCS Approved Trainer, during her session “Documentation Discrepancies on OIG Audits” at AAPC’s AUDITCON conference, Nov. 8-9, 2023.
Regardless of the legitimacy of the OIG audits, the best recourse for MAOs is always compliance with federal guidelines. To that end, Pritchett’s AUDITCON session shed some light on which diagnosis codes the OIG considers high risk and what must be documented to support the resulting hierarchical condition category (HCC) coding and subsequent risk adjustment payments to MAOs.
The Medicare Advantage
The CMS-HCC risk adjustment payment model compensates MAOs for the financial burden associated with insuring patients with certain acute and chronic illnesses. Payments are based on risk scores tied to HCC codes, and HCC codes are tied to diagnosis codes. When diagnosis codes assigned to HCC codes are misreported, MAOs are overpaid, and the integrity of the program is compromised. According to a 2023 MedPAC status report, “Between 2007 and 2023, MA coding intensity generated nearly $124 billion in excess payments.”
The OIG’s focus is always on clinical documentation in these audits, and there is much debate among stakeholders on what “sufficient” documentation looks like. MAOs generally disagree with the OIG’s findings and discount the integrity of the audits.
High-Risk Diagnosis Codes
According to the OIG, the following diagnoses are most at risk for being miscoded due to failure to follow coding and documentation requirement guidelines:
- Acute stroke
- Acute heart attack
- Acute stroke and heart attack
- Major depressive disorder
- Embolism
- Vascular claudication
- Lung, breast, colon, and prostate cancers
The main issue with coding these conditions is knowing when they are current or a history of. History of codes are not assigned an HCC code, so they are not risk adjusted.
Acute Stroke
A cerebrovascular accident (CVA) or stroke should be documented as “acute” only at the time of the original encounter. “Treatment of a stroke is rarely, if ever, done in an outpatient setting,” Pritchett said. “It is most likely to take place in the emergency department or as an inpatient in a hospital.” Never say never, but odds are you will never code an acute stroke in a physician’s office.
CVA documentation should include type, cause, laterality of occlusion, and involvement of precerebral or cerebral arteries.
For stroke aftercare visits, Pritchett advises: If no deficits are documented, code Z86.73. If the patient has a residual neurological deficit related to a stroke and/or it’s affecting recovery, assign a code from category I69.-. And make sure you understand the deficits that are considered sequelae after a CVA such as dysphasia (difficulty swallowing) and dysphagia (speech impairment).
OIG audit scope: Patient receives one acute stroke diagnosis on only one physician claim during service year but did not have diagnosis on a corresponding inpatient or outpatient hospital claim.
ICD-10-CM codes: I63.-, I97.8-
HCC code: 249 (v28) | 100 (earlier versions)
Time for a quick review! Watch video 1 to play “What Would You Code?”
Acute Heart Attack
For encounters occurring while the myocardial infarction (MI) is equal to or less than four weeks old, including transfers to other acute care settings, and the MI meets the definition of another type, a diagnosis code from category I21 may continue to be reported. If a subsequent MI of one type occurs within four weeks of an MI of a different type, assign the appropriate code from category I21. “Do not assign a code from category I22,” Pritchett said.
If a type 1 ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI), code I21.4, evolves into a STEMI, assign code I21.01-I21.03; if a type 1 STEMI converts to a non-STEMI due to thrombolytic therapy, “it’s still coded as a STEMI,” Pritchett said. If a type 1 STEMI is a transmural MI and the site is not documented, assign code I21.3.
OIG audit scope: One or more diagnoses mapping to acute myocardial infarction (AMI) or unstable angina and other acute ischemia heart disease on one claim without a corresponding inpatient claim 60 days before or after the physician or outpatient claim.
Per the OIG, “A diagnosis for a less severe manifestation of a disease in the related-disease group is more appropriate.”
ICD-10-CM codes: I20.0, I21.-, I23.-, I24.-, I25.7-, I51.-
HCC codes: 228, 229 (v28) | 87, 86 (earlier versions)
Time for a quick review! Watch video 2 to play “What Would You Code?”
Major Depressive Disorder
There are several tools that providers can use to diagnose major depressive disorder (MDD). These tools, such as the PHQ9 and DSM-5, enable the provider to determine whether the episode is initial or recurrent (at least two months since the last episode), the severity (mild, moderate, severe), and the clinical status.
OIG audit scope: An enrollee received one MDD diagnosis (that mapped to the HCC for major depressive, bipolar, and paranoid disorders) on only one claim during the service year but did not have an antidepressant medication dispensed on his or her behalf. In these instances, the major depressive disorder diagnoses may not be supported in the medical records.
“Patients with depression should be seen at least annually to monitor for potential side effects of medications and to manage those conditions,” Pritchett said. A comprehensive reconciliation, describing each medication, indication, the length of treatment, the benefits, any side effects, and plans for continued treatment helps to ensure adequate documentation is obtained in support of MDD codes.
ICD-10-CM coding: F32.-, F33.-
HCC code: 59
Acute Pulmonary Embolism
“This is a blood clot that forms in your leg and travels to your lungs and stays there,” Pritchett explained.
Deep vein thrombosis (DVT) can be acute or chronic. An acute DVT is typically less than two weeks old. A subacute DVT is more than two weeks old and less than six weeks. A chronic DVT is more than six months old.
Coding requires you to be able to ask and answer, “Is the DVT acute, chronic, or does the patient have a history of?” “There is no specific coding guideline for when a DVT becomes chronic,” Pritchett said. It’s up to the clinician to document this. Documentation should also include site, laterality, and treatment plan.
“If the DVT has resolved over time, document and code Z86.718 Personal history of other venous thrombosis and embolism,” Pritchett said.
OIG audit scope: An enrollee received one diagnosis that mapped to either the HCC for vascular disease or to the HCC for vascular disease with complications (embolism HCCs) on only one claim during the service year but did not have an anticoagulant medication dispensed on his or her behalf. An anticoagulant medication is typically used to treat an embolism.
“In these instances,” the OIG says, “a diagnosis of history of embolism (an indication that the provider is evaluating a prior acute embolism diagnosis, which does not map to an HCC) typically should have been used.”
ICD-10-CM codes: I26.-, I74.-, I82.-
HCC codes: 267, 264 (v28) | 107 (earlier versions)
Time for a quick review! Watch video 3 to play “What Would You Code?”
Vascular Claudication
“Peripheral vascular disease is a really broad term and a vague diagnosis,” Pritchett said. “Documentation should be as specific as possible to describe the particular type of disease.” A patient may need pain, high cholesterol, and high blood pressure management, and surgery may be required. It’s also important to pay attention to the parenthetical notes (Excludes1, code also, etc.) for the codes you are assigning, and code to the highest level of specificity that documentation allows.
OIG audit scope: An enrollee received one diagnosis related to vascular claudication (that mapped to the HCC for vascular disease) on only one claim during the service year but had not received one of these diagnoses during the two preceding years but had medication dispensed on his or her behalf that is frequently dispensed for a diagnosis of neurogenic claudication.
“In these instances, the diagnosis related to vascular claudication diagnoses may not be supported in the medical records,” the OIG states.
Lung, Breast, Colon, and Prostate Cancers
Documentation should identify the classification of the cancer (i.e., primary, malignant, secondary malignant, benign, in situ, or uncertain). The anatomic location should be noted, as well as whether the cancer is active (current) or a personal history of. All active treatments and any related conditions must also be noted in clear terms.
OIG audit scope: A patient received a cancer diagnosis on only one claim during the service year and did not have surgical therapy, radiation treatments, or chemotherapy drug treatments administered within a six-month period either before or after the diagnosis.
According to the OIG, “In these instances, a diagnosis of history of cancer typically should have been used.”
ICD-10-CM codes: C33, C34.-, C50.-, C18.-, C61
HCC codes: 20, 22, 23 (v28) | 9, 10, 11, 12 (earlier versions)
Time for a quick review! Watch video 4 to play “What Would You Code?”
Get the OIG Toolkit
The OIG recently posted a toolkit that MAOs and other entities can use to audit their claims. It uses the SQL programming language to assist with analyzing large sets of MA claims data. MAO audits using the same techniques as the OIG to identify and evaluate high-risk diagnosis codes may highlight areas in need of clinical documentation improvement. MAOs could then communicate the findings to providers.
Resources:
Toolkit To Help Decrease Improper Payments in Medicare Advantage
The Medicare Advantage Program Status Report
- PLA Code Changes for CPT® 2027 - November 5, 2026
- CMS Issues October 2026 ASC Payment Update - November 4, 2026
- NCA Reconsiders Hepatitis C Screening Coverage - October 15, 2026



Could I please have the link stating the audit scope for vascular and MDD.. the link in the publication doesn’t work.
The link has been fixed.