Improve Your Revenue Integrity Program Using KPIs
- By Lee Fifield
- In Healthcare Business Monthly
- August 1, 2024
- Comments Off on Improve Your Revenue Integrity Program Using KPIs
To develop a successful revenue integrity program, pay close attention to key performance indicators.
In his 2024 REVCON session “The Blueprint for a Sustainable Revenue Integrity Program,” Stuart Newsome, CPCO, vice president at Infinx Healthcare, provided insight on how to fortify the revenue cycle. A crucial part of getting paid is relying on key performance indicators (KPIs). These metrics measure performance over time to help medical practices improve process efficiencies and increase revenue. Let’s review some of the top KPIs in medical billing and how to be proactive in managing the denials process.
Key KPIs
Capturing as many analytics as possible will help you avoid and manage denials. Five effective KPIs that can help fortify revenue integrity are:
1. First pass rate: The most common KPI. This rate shows how many claims were accepted on the first attempt versus the number of claims submitted over a period of time.
First pass rate = Claims accepted ÷ Claims submitted
The greater the first pass rate, the better your revenue cycle management (RCM) medical billing parameters are. The first pass rate determines how successful your RCM, billing department, or clearinghouse is. This rate is typically between 95 and 97 percent. It’s an easy rate to accomplish because it indicates that you’ve filled out your claims correctly. Getting claims through at this stage does not mean they are clean, however.
2. Claim denial rate: This indicator tracks the percentage of claims denied. It shows an organization its payer compliance capabilities, as well as the ability of payers to accurately reimburse claims.
Claim denial rate = Total claims denied ÷ Aggregate claims remitted
The national denial rate average is 15-20 percent. Best practices are considered 5 percent, while 7 percent is considered acceptable. Consider this, however: If a first pass rate is 97 percent, why wouldn’t the denial rate be 3 percent?
The claim must be appropriate to be accepted for adjudication. All the right boxes must be filled in with all the data completed. If not, the claim will be denied or rejected. “The danger of first pass claim rate is a lot of people feel that that’s a rejection or denial,” said Newsome. “It’s actually a return to provider. It didn’t have a chance to be adjudicated, so it can’t be rejected or denied. They’re just sending it back to you to make corrections. And sometimes that’s misinterpreted. There are some things the denial rate may not catch.”
Hidden issues within this KPI that skew denial rate include:
- Overlooking line-level denials in paid claims. Claims that do not reveal denials at a line-item level may not get entered properly into the denials management process.
- Submitting charges that are lower than the allowed contracted amounts, causing underpayments.
- Failing to report CPT® combination codes (e.g., billing an injection code without the administration code or vice versa). Bundling/unbundling and evaluation and management service undercoding are also problematic.
- Inappropriate use of modifiers or not using modifiers effectively.
- Not issuing Advance Beneficiary Notices.
Many people don’t realize the impact of undercoding. “I call it an epidemic,” said Newsome. “If you’re not coding to the level of service that you need to code to then you’re really shooting yourself in both feet.” Providers need to be convinced that their documentation supports a higher level of service. Many providers erroneously think they will avoid an audit by undercoding. “You’re still going to be an outlier,” said Newsome. “And guess what? Outliers get audited.” Code according to the documentation guidelines and code according to what’s documented.
3. Clean claim rate: This tracks the rate at which insurance claims have been successfully processed and reimbursed the first time they were submitted.
Clean claim rate = Clean claims ÷ Claims accepted
You can only work so many claims in a day, so it’s important to find an efficient process that results in clean claims.
A clean claim is defined as:
- Having no errors or omissions; and
- Can be processed without additional information or verification of information by a human, third-party service, or automation.
A clean claim will go through the process unabated without any assistance. A clean claim contains the following correct information:
- Each procedure code has a supporting valid diagnosis code.
- There are no potential issues or questions regarding medical necessity.
- The patient’s coverage was in effect on the date of services.
- The patient’s insurance covers the service provided.
- The claim submission includes all the required patient information such as full name, mailing address, and date of birth.
- The claim identifies the payer, including the correct payer identification number, group number, and mailing address.
- All required claim information is in the correct field.
- The claim is submitted within the timely filing window.
All policies should be reviewed so there are no questions regarding medical necessity and covered services. Ensure your electronic health record can adequately differentiate patients with the same or similar name. This is a high-level view, but if you check all of these boxes, your claim is most likely clean.
Don’t allow claims with errors to be labeled as “clean” to boost your numbers or for any other reason. This results in giving the organization a lack of analytical insight, eliminating a clear picture of where problems lay, and offering no opportunities to improve.
4. Cost to collect rate: This rate measures the costs that drive revenue, including expenses related to staff salaries, technology, and revenue cycle efficiency and productivity. What it costs to make a clean claim also counts as cost to collect.
Cost to collect = Total revenue cycle cost ÷ Total patient services cash collected
The total revenue cycle cost is found on the income statement, while the total patient services cash collected is found on the balance sheet. Best practice for the average cost to collect is 2.9 percent, while 4 percent is acceptable. If you have more than 4 percent, it’s time to review your processes to find efficiencies.
To determine the average number of claims an employee can work, factor in the number of touches it takes to rework a claim, including:
- The rejection or denial
- Calling the payer for details
- Researching coding mistakes
- Refiling the claim
- Posting another denial if rejected again
Researching coding mistakes can go in many directions. You may know where to find the answer immediately or you may have to read the medical record and/or consult the provider. The average cost to rework a claim is $25.20, which can quickly add up to hundreds of thousands of dollars each year.
5. Final denial write-off percentage: Denial write-offs are a percentage of net patient services. When you’ve exhausted all efforts to get paid without success, it’s time to write off these sums.
Denial write-off percentage = Net dollars written off ÷ Average monthly patient service
Many organizations choose to write off uncollected claims to avoid labor costs associated with achieving a clean claim. “Why chase bad money?” asked Newsome. “If you’re not going to receive it, if it’s aged, if it’s already outside the parameters of timely filing, there’s just no need to spend any more effort on this.”
Discrepancy amounts should be recorded as bad debt to reduce revenue by the unpaid amount. But be aware that older electronic management systems assume write-offs are due to contractual allowances. “That could be a big no-no because it’s actually a false positive,” said Newsome. Instead of writing off the amount, the system attributes it to the contractual amount. This can result in falsely low bad debt rates which look good on paper but fail to identify potential problems. Without this false number, “You can actually recover more revenue and get to the root cause much faster,” Newsome added. Don’t erase the opportunity to attempt recovery again. A higher bad debt rate correctly identifying these amounts enables organizations to take steps in recovering this otherwise lost revenue.
Audit the Denials Management Process
Never assume your RCM is working as planned just because you have excellent processes and systems in place. If you are still receiving too many denials after incorporating a good plan, consider the following in a review of claims and remits:
- Outdated software or software with no timely updates (check clearinghouses)
- Users skipping edits to get claims out the door
- Not following up in a timely manner and passing refiling deadlines
- Claims initially paid that had to be refunded later
- Paid claims which didn’t keep up with fee schedules for different carriers and payers
Check your appeal deadlines per carrier; the appeals process may not be equal across the board with all carriers. Additionally, determine your rate of resubmission. On average, 60 percent of claims are resubmitted nationally. Of that number, 18 percent are never collected.
Get Smart
Denials management is usually a reactive process, but you can make denials work for you in the long run. “Don’t waste a failure,” said Newsome. To fortify revenue integrity, build backwards by being proactive and turning smart denials into smart edits.
Prioritize top remittance codes by identifying trends by payer. Payers must follow the statute of using claim adjustment reason codes (CARCS) and remittance advice remark codes (RARCs). “But there’s no regulation that they need to use it for the same definition and define it and tell you exactly why that claim was denied,” said Newsome. “Until we get that legislation in place, you need to identify trends per payer and make sure you can also determine the root cause of denial.”
Determining which CARCS and RARCS are the top denials helps you understand when it’s worth the effort to go through the appeals process. Once you discover how often a denial occurs, ask yourself, ‘Can I create an edit for this? Can I make this proactive?’ And if so, ‘Can I create automation for it to free up time?’ Answering these questions can help you convert key denials into preventive edits.
Tip: Don’t rely on clearinghouses for RCM. They typically focus on the first pass claim rate edits.
- CMS Issues 2027 ESRD Prospective Payment System Final Rule - November 5, 2026
- I Am AAPC: Diane Costa, CPC, CPCO, CPMA, CRC - November 2, 2026
- Expanding Electronic Prior Authorization for Self-Funded Health Plans - October 30, 2026

