Patients Gain Appeal Rights When Their Hospital Status Changes
- By Renee Dustman
- In Billing
- October 16, 2024
- 2 Comments
If a hospital status change from inpatient to observation affects a Medicare beneficiary’s coverage, they may be able to reverse it.
It isn’t uncommon for a hospital to change a patient’s status from inpatient to outpatient. There are significant differences between inpatient (Part A) and outpatient (Part B) coverage, however. A patient can go into the hospital thinking their Part A insurance will cover everything only to find out they’ve been reclassified to outpatient status midway, and their stay is no longer covered. A final rule published in the Oct. 15, 2024, Federal Register by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) aims to give patients with Original Medicare some recourse when this happens.
The Medicare Program: Appeal Rights for Certain Changes in Patient Status final rule establishes a process for eligible Medicare beneficiaries to appeal a denial of their Part A coverage because they were reclassified from inpatient to outpatient at some point during their hospital stay.
What the Rule Means for Beneficiaries
The new appeals process applies to patients with Original Medicare (Parts A/B) who meet the following criteria:
- The beneficiary was officially admitted to inpatient status at the hospital;
- The beneficiary was reclassified by the hospital to outpatient status;
- The beneficiary received or will receive a Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) or Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice (MOON) indicating the observation services are not covered under Medicare Part A; and
- The beneficiary was either not enrolled in Part B at the time of their hospitalization or stayed at the hospital for three or more consecutive days but was or will be designated as inpatient for fewer than three days and was or will be admitted to a skilled nursing facility (SNF) sometime during the 30 days following the hospital stay.
Beneficiaries who pursued an administrative appeal and received a final decision before Sept. 4, 2011, are excluded from this type of appeal. CMS explains this process on its consumer Medicare.gov website.
There are three different appeals procedures:
Expedited appeals:Medicare beneficiaries who disagree with the hospital’s decision to reclassify their status from inpatient to observation, which would result in a denial of Part A coverage, may request an expedited appeal prior to being discharged from the hospital. After receiving patient records from the hospital, the Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO) has one day to make a determination. The type of appeal is similar to the existing appeals process for expedited hospital discharges.
Standard appeals: Medicare beneficiaries who qualified for an expedited appeal, but didn’t start the process until after they left the hospital, may file a standard appeal.
Retrospective appeals: Medicare beneficiaries have 365 calendar days from the implementation date of the final rule to request a retrospective appeal for denial of Part A coverage of hospital services (and certain SNF services) due to a change status, for dates of service dating back to Jan. 1, 2009.
If the beneficiary can show that their inpatient admission satisfied the relevant criteria for Part A coverage and that the hospital utilization review committee’s determination to the contrary was erroneous, then the reclassification as an outpatient will be disregarded.
CMS states in the final rule, “We would like to emphasize, as we did in the proposed rule, that we strongly encourage beneficiaries or their representatives to submit with their appeal request all available medical records related to the hospitalization and, as applicable, SNF services, and documentation of amounts paid out of pocket for care that was not covered under Part A.”
To accomplish this, an eligibility contractor should be assigned to work with the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) to obtain the relevant records, including hospital records that document the inpatient admission, orders for observation services, diagnosis and treatment notes, orders and testing results, discharge planning notes, and SNF records (if applicable).
If an eligible beneficiary requests an expedited appeal within the allowed time, they should not be billed during the QIO appeals process. If the appeal is not timely, however, the hospital may bill a beneficiary before this appeals process is complete.
What the Rule Means for Hospitals
CMS made a couple of revisions to the retrospective appeals process based on public comments to the proposed rule. Of note:
- The timeframe for providers to submit a Part A claim following a favorable decision on behalf of the beneficiary is extended from 180 calendar days to 365 calendar days.
- The timeframe for providers to submit records as requested by the MAC is extended from 60 calendar days to 120 calendar days.
CMS also clarified a few points in the final rule that commenters said were not clear in the proposed rule:
In the event of a successful appeal, the hospital must refund any Part B payments collected for the outpatient services before submitting a Part A inpatient claim for such services. Recoupment includes monies paid by Medicare and/or the patient or other individual. Part B payments will not be recouped if the hospital chooses not to submit a Part A claim. Watch the CMS website for instructions on submitting or adjusting claims.
CMS also acknowledges in the final rule concerns raised by commenters about the extended lookback period for retrospective appeals and the ability of providers to locate the medical records. Although all reasonable efforts should be made, CMS says providers will not be penalized if they can’t locate records for dates of service beyond the seven-year record retention timeframe.
Hospitals will be required to “deliver, as soon as possible after certain conditions are met and prior to release from the hospital, a new standardized beneficiary notice, informing eligible beneficiaries of the change in their status, the resulting effect on Medicare coverage of their stay, and their appeal rights if they wish to challenge that change,” CMS explains in the final rule. This new notice will be called the Medicare Change of Status Notice (MCSN), which follows the format and structure of the Important Message from Medicare (IM) form hospitals use to inform patients of their right to appeal an inpatient hospital discharge.
A single Medicare-certified hospital will deliver on average of fewer than three notices annually, CMS estimates. “While we understand the act of delivering new notices, even in a low volume, is an appreciable increase in responsibilities for hospitals, we do not believe the new appeals process will significantly affect operations or staffing within hospitals,” CMS states in the final rule.
CMS has not set implementation dates for these regulations, which are effective Oct. 11, 2024, but says on its website that the target date for retrospective appeals is Jan. 1, 2025, and Feb. 14, 2025, for prospective appeals. Watch for new details on the CMS website.
- PLA Code Changes for CPT® 2027 - November 5, 2026
- CMS Issues October 2026 ASC Payment Update - November 4, 2026
- NCA Reconsiders Hepatitis C Screening Coverage - October 15, 2026


BIG error in your post-
“The beneficiary was either enrolled in Part B at the time”
this should be “not enrolled” – the patient has part A but not part B and status is changed
Thank you for pointing that out, Dr. Hirsch! It has been corrected.