Health Information Compliance Alert
Just How Valuable Are Electronic Health Records?
PDF
Concrete data on HIT's value is a little sketchy, researchers say.
Reliable research on health information technology's efficacy is scarce.
A 2006 study showed statistical models suggest that HIT could make healthcare safer, more effective, and more efficient. But the Southern California Evidence-based Practice Center in Santa Monica, which performed the study for the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality,found experimental evidence supporting HIT to be limited.
Critics: Show Me the Science
"It is not possible to draw firm conclusions" about which HIT methods are most likely to achieve health benefits,the report said, "and the assessment of costs is even more uncertain."
Existing evidence doesn't tell "who pays for" and "who benefits from" HIT in any healthcare organization "except those, such as Kaiser and the VA, that are responsible for paying for and delivering all the care," the report continued.
Some just aren't sold on HIT. In a Washington Post oped piece, two professors said the benefits of electronic health records have been "greatly exaggerated."
"Large, randomized controlled studies -- the 'gold standard' of evidence -- in this country and Britain have found that electronic records with computerized decision support did not result in a single improvement in any measure of quality of care for patients with chronic conditions including heart disease and asthma," wrote Stephen B. Soumerai, ScD, a professor of ambulatory care and prevention at Harvard Medical School,and Sumit R.Majumdar, MD, MPH, an associate professor at the University of Alberta's Department of Medicine.
"Health IT has not been proven to save money," they added, and cited cases in which EHRs were the root of harm to patients.
Advocates: You Get Out of HIT What You Put Into It
Lack of certainty doesn't turn everyone off HIT.
Prakash Hingorani, director of strategic solutions at Marlabs Inc., is an EHR believer. Marlabs provides IT services in the banking and financial services, healthcare, media, and legal sectors.Bottom line: HIT can play a powerful role in cutting healthcare costs, he says.
"Doctors will need to be trained in the new technology,"he says. "Reaching out to individual doctors will be a challenge."
Meanwhile, hospitals, which generally already have digitized information systems, "will need to address the challenges of having disparate systems talk to each other."
"Different providers of EHR systems will need to come up with interfaces or a common standard for interfacing," he says.
HIT vendors are lining up for a slice of that $19 billion federal pie. But how does one know a good system from a bad one? Robert Lamberts, MD, an Augusta, Ga.-based physician who is board certified in internal medicine and pediatrics said EHRs can contribute to a practice -- or they can mess one up.
Beyond the purchase: "The most important factor in success is the implementation process," Lamberts said in his blog. A poorly implemented EHR system "makes medical practice harder. A well implemented EHR doesn't just function, it improves quality and profitability."
He offered these suggestions to fellow providers:
• Visit a doctor who is using an EHR system successfully. "When you visit, make sure you ask them about the implementation process," he says. "How did they do it and how hard was it?"
• Buy a product that is certified by the Certification Commission for Health Information Technology, a government task force established to set standards for EMR products;and
• Search specialty society Web sites for tools to help choose an EHR system.
Resources: Visit Lambert's blog at www.distractible.org.Learn about the Certification Commission for Health Information Technology: www.cchit.org.
Health Information Compliance Alert
- IDENTITY THEFT:
No Red Flags Program? You Could Be Losing Thousands
Tip: Institute your Red Flags program ASAP. You may think the government is implementing the [...] - Identity Theft:
Act Quickly If Your Practice Identifies a Red Flag
Identity theft is nearly a $50 billion industry. You've implemented a Red Flags program at [...] - Information Technology:
Feds Roll Out Free Health IT Software
Federal Health Architecture aims to help providers CONNECT. The Department of Health and Human Services' [...] - Electronic Health Records:
Just How Valuable Are Electronic Health Records?
Concrete data on HIT's value is a little sketchy, researchers say. The federal government is [...] - Compliance:
OIG Advisory Opinion Process Can Be Long,Arduous -- and Costly
The Advisory Opinion will give you peace of mind, so proceed with requesting one if [...] - Compliance:
Signed Certification Statements Are Essential to Your Medicare Enrollment, CMS Says
Plus: CMS clarifies IPPE reimbursement policy. If you're using the PECOS system, your work doesn't [...] - Reader Questions:
Send Your NPP to Participants Only
Question: We work with an employer-sponsored health plan, but we are confused as to who [...] - Reader Questions:
Your Compliance Is Not Technology-Dependent
Question: Our tech team wants to use voice over Internet protocol (VoIP) and Web cameras [...] - Reader Questions:
Set a Standard Fee for Patient Copies
Question: We recently realized that our remote sites charge different amounts for patients to receive [...] - INDUSTRY NEWS:
Texas Hospital Pays Nearly $10 Million for Inflated Outlier Charges
'The consultant told me to do it' isn't a valid defense. If you've increased your [...] - In other news…
CMS wants to get a handle on the number of Medicare patients that are readmitted [...]