Eli's Rehab Report

Published on Fri Mar 22, 2013 PDF

Key: Learn to praise the employee, don’t just criticize.

Are performance appraisals in your facility just a matter of paperwork, or do they really help managers and employees identify growth opportunities? The good news is the process doesn’t have to be trying and time-consuming. Try these best practices to get your performance appraisal processes on the right track.

Focus on the Positives, not Just Negatives

One of the biggest mistakes that managers make during performance appraisals is to focus on the areas for improvement or what the employee is doing wrong, rather than highlighting the positive things the employee is doing, says Bill Repp, author of the nationally syndicated column Working Best, based in Rochester, N.Y. You should match the ratio of good performance to bad performance to the amount of time you spend discussing good performance versus correction, he adds.

“If you have an employee that really only about 20 percent [of his performance] needs to be corrected, then out of an hour performance appraisal, 48 minutes should be spent praising the employee and talking about all the great things he has done, and only 12 minutes talking about where he can improve,” Repp explains.

Adopt a Good Appraisal System

If you don’t have a good appraisal system, none of your performance appraisals are going to be effective. You should keep these three aspects in mind when setting up your performance appraisals system, Repp says:

1. A good system requires periodic evaluation. The performance appraisal should be ongoing, but there should be some formal time set up to review the performance. Don’t let managers think passing an employee in the hall and saying “You’re doing a great job” suffices as a performance appraisal.

2. Judgments should be made on categories or skills decided in advance between the manager and the employee. The employee should know ahead of time what is expected of him and what criteria he’ll be judged upon.

3. The communication between the supervisor and the employee must be honest and open. Without open communication, there can’t be any growth.

Pointer: Make sure your top management staff stresses that performance appraisals should not be a 15-minute meeting during which the manager just has the employee sign the appraisal. “Top management has to say that you need to be spending an hour or two with that performance process to make sure that the employee knows what’s expected and how you’re going to be supporting it,” Repp says.

You should also make sure every performance appraisal is written out and also includes a discussion. Remember to include both positives and negatives in both the written and oral components.

Be Firm, but Fair, With Corrective Action

There will be times when an employee needs some sort of corrective action. In such cases, make sure you consistently follow the same corrective process with all employees to ensure fair treatment and make sure you’re being reasonable.

Take notes: Document the entire process. Encouraging managers to make notes throughout the year about an employee, documenting dates and times of both good and bad performance, will make the performance appraisal process easier and more effective. Good records provide credibility as well. Then you can use that documentation to promote positive corrective action.

Caution: When you have to take corrective action, make sure you don’t avoid the situation, rely on threats or punishment to motivate improvement, apply rules legalistically, or let personal biases or emotions affect your decisions, Repp warns.