Were there other procedures? if there are only 2 then only the column 2 code should have the -59. Though it sounds like some payers are still considering 11102 to be the column 2 code. I think it may depending on the version of NCCI that is being used i think they may have flipped them:
Find-A-Code Note: The
official NCCI Edits data lists 11102 as column 1 and 17000 as column 2, but we have received customer reports of denials and that 17000 should be column 1 (paid) and 11102 should be column 2 (denied without modifiers). If this affects you, please contact your Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) for further clarification.